Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is the second episode of Glee: The New York Story 's second season. It premiered on November 19, 2013.

Plot
Rachel and Finn spend some alone time in their room while Rachel shows Finn the lingerie that she plans to wear on their honeymoon. Finn becomes dejected that her lingerie isn't for in the moment and begins to question why they're hosting Thanksgiving at their house. Rachel explains they save airfare and it would be their first New York Thanksgiving. She then asks Finn when did he plan on telling her that Puck was going to stay in the loft. Finn admits it slipped his mind but Rachel agrees to let Puck stay.

Meanwhile, Santana ponders when Puck plans to go home, only for Puck to tell her that he's staying permanently. Santana becomes irate and ultimately locks herself in the bathroom, but when Puck mentions to Finn that Santana isn't happy about it, Finn reminds him that Brittany is coming to New York, which in turn makes Santana nervous. Finn then offers for Puck to come with him and Rachel to the supermarket but Puck declines. He however regrets his decision when Santana continues to be irate.

Kurt is about to leave Vogue when he notices Isabelle still working. He questions why she is still working when she can be home for the holidays, but Isabelle reveals she can't afford to go home. With Isabelle unable to see her family, Kurt offers for Isabelle to have Thanksgiving with him and his friends at the loft. Isabelle is initially hesitant because she feels she's intruding but Kurt assures her that the more the merrier. Isabelle eventually takes on Kurt's offer and Kurt puts her in a cab so she can be pulled away from her work.

At the loft, Santana becomes frustrated when she feels that Puck is doing nothing to help them, but Kurt reminds her that Puck's only job was to open the door to guests. Kurt and Santana argue about Puck, but Puck reveals he can hear the both of them talking about him, which begins to annoy him. As Puck and Santana are about to quarrel, they hear a knock on the door, which is revealed to be Quinn. Puck is speechless as Quinn hands Puck dessert for the party, with Kurt revealing that Blaine and Isabelle will be at the party any moment. Santana is perplexed that Kurt invited Isabelle but Quinn notices that Puck is acting out of the ordinary.

As Rachel and Finn cook the turkey, Brittany comes to visit, but Santana can immediately sense that there's something Brittany isn't telling her. Before Santana can ponder what's going on with Brittany, Isabelle's friends arrive. Kurt then calls Isabelle to ponder where she is, and Isabelle shows up, with her, Rachel, Kurt and the rest of the party singing Let's Have A Kiki.

Quinn is able to get Puck alone and realizes his odd behavior is because he was nervous seeing her. Quinn and Puck put their feelings out in the open, before Quinn gives Puck a kiss, the two of them admitting that it was the best Thanksgiving yet.

As Rachel is admitting that she had a good Thanksgiving, she gets a call from Rupert Grint, informing her that she landed the role of Fanny Brice. She tells everyone and everyone congratulates her, with Rachel feeling like everything is finally coming up for her.

However, Santana and Brittany have an opposite experience; Santana tells Brittany they can finally be together, but Brittany informs her that they can't, mainly because she is dating Sam now, and feels Santana has been indecisive ever since she moved to New York City. Santana is heartbroken that Brittany doesn't want to be with her, and finds herself at a nearby park. Puck finds her and gives Santana a jacket. That's when Santana mentions Brittany doesn't want to be with her and cries into Puck's arms, revealing that this Thanksgiving has been the "worst Thanksgiving ever".

Special Guest Star

 * Sarah Jessica Parker as Isabelle Wright

Guest Stars

 * Dianna Agron as Quinn Fabray
 * Darren Criss as Blaine Anderson
 * Heather Morris as Brittany Pierce